EUDR Risk Alerts: What To Do When Automated Deforestation Checks Flag Your Supplier
A practical guide to interpreting medium and high risk results from the Geocledian EUDR Check – and how our Expert Assessment service helps you handle flagged cases with confidence.
Introduction
Automated deforestation checks have become the backbone of EUDR compliance. Our EUDR Check API scales across thousands of parcels, applies a consistent, auditable methodology, and delivers results at a pace no manual process could match. But as you continue to check you will face a certain percentage of true deforestation risks detected. Simple to overcome false positives are in our system an exception. But no automated system may resolve every case – and the EUDR itself acknowledges this by demanding a risk-based, documented due diligence process rather than a binary pass/fail mechanism.
This raises a practical question every operator using our EUDR Check will eventually face: What happens when the automated check flags a parcel with medium or high deforestation risk?
In this article, we explain how our Expert Assessment service addresses exactly this gap: what types of alerts occur, why not every risk alert reflects genuine non-compliance, and how structured, documented expert validation turns an unresolved risk flag into a defensible decision – quickly and at a fraction of the cost of an on-site audit.
Why Risk Alerts Need Attention – and Care
A flagged deforestation risk is not a routine notification. It carries potentially severe consequences for everyone involved:
- For the importer: the shipment may be blocked at customs, or the order cancelled – with contractual and financial fallout.
- For the supplier: goods from non-compliant plots can no longer be placed on the EU market at all.
Conversely, treating every alert as confirmed EUDR relevant deforestation would be equally problematic: rejecting shipments damages supplier relationships and disrupts supply chains .
In our experience with automated EUDR Checks, roughly 3–6% of parcels are flagged with medium or high deforestation risk. The majority of these represent genuine risks that require action. But a meaningful share does not – and this is precisely where the operational dilemma lies. Neither blanket acceptance nor blanket rejection is a viable strategy.
Understanding the Sources of Positives
Not every flagged risk reflects actual deforestation in the EUDR sense. Alarms typically fall into the following categories:
- Point Coordinates or boundary inaccuracies: In case of point coordinates an area of 4ha surrounding the point is checked. If a deforestation alert occurs it often does on the edges. Due to the nature of points the exact boundary of the production area is unknown. Similar issues may apply to big obviously inaccurate boundaries. To overcome the issue it is recommended to request the exact location of the production area instead of a point or a corse geometry.
- Baseline map limitations: Any assessment relies on official and validated baseline maps indicating EUDR relevant forest coverage. But forest maps can misinterpret agroforestry systems, sometimes even plantations as forest or simply overestimate forest cover at the 31 December 2020 cut-off date. Baseline maps are datasets like any other – they contain errors and vary in quality depending on the geographical location. The problem may also occur in the opposite direction. Forest maps in quite some cases lack forest plantations. This leads to plausibility errors when declaring wood as a commodity on these locations.
- Natural events: Landslides, storms, or fires may cause genuine tree cover loss. If the area shows no signs of conversion to agricultural land, this falls outside the EUDR definition of deforestation (though continued monitoring may be advisable, as conversion could follow later).
- Non-agricultural land use change: If, for example, houses or roads have been built on the former forest area, deforestation is confirmed – but the EUDR targets conversion to agricultural use, which is absent in this case.
Understanding these distinctions is essential: an automated risk alert is the beginning of an assessment, if it indicates possible risks further investigation is needed.
The Operator’s Dilemma
When a medium or high risk alert arrives, the operator faces a choice, and none of the obvious options is entirely satisfying:
- Reject the shipment outright – safe from a compliance perspective, but potentially a costly overreaction if the alert turns out to be non EUDR relevant.
- Commission an on-site audit – the most thorough option, but slow, expensive, and hard to scale if necessary.
- Accept and document – commercially convenient, but difficult to defend in an audit if the risk later proves genuine.
What is needed is a middle ground: a validation step that is faster and more affordable than on-site audits, more rigorous than internal desk review, and documented well enough to stand up to scrutiny.
This is the space our Expert Assessment service was designed for.
The Geocledian Expert Assessment
The Expert Assessment is a manual validation service for medium and high deforestation risk results from our automated EUDR Check. Its purpose is to validate the automated result – and to recommend concrete next steps where genuine doubt remains.
How it works
An EUDR trained remote sensing interpreter reviews the flagged parcel along a guided assessment protocol:
- Verify the baseline land cover: Is the forest classification for 31 December 2020 plausible for this parcel, or does the baseline map overestimate forest cover here?
- Verify the forest disturbance: Is vegetation loss actually detectable at or before the stated harvest date?
- Check the EUDR rule set: Where deforestation is confirmed – has the land actually been converted to agricultural use, or is another land use change (settlements, infrastructure) or natural cause more plausible?
Where available, Very-High-Resolution (VHR) satellite imagery supplements the standard Sentinel-2 time series, allowing the interpreter to distinguish details that 10m-resolution data cannot resolve – forest structure, bushes, garden structures, small forest patches, individual buildings, small roads or the precise boundary of a slide area.
Quality assurance
Every assessment follows a four-eyes principle: a second reviewer checks the assessment before it is finalised. All steps are documented with notes and screenshots of the data sources used, so the full reasoning chain remains traceable – for the operator, for auditors, and for authorities.
Importantly, the assessment uses independent, publicly available remote information (plus agreed commercial datasets where relevant). It does not rely on information supplied by the supplier – a deliberate design decision to preserve neutrality.
Possible outcomes
Each Expert Assessment concludes with one of three findings:
- Deforestation likely or possible – including comments and recommended next steps (typically local on-site verification).
- Deforestation confirmed, but no conversion to agricultural land – e.g., construction detected instead. Not a risk under EUDR.
- Deforestation not confirmed – including the documented reasoning behind the dismissal.
In every case, the operator receives not just a verdict, but an explained and documented one.
Scope
- Covers all EUDR-relevant commodities (cattle, cocoa, coffee, oil palm, rubber, soya, wood).
- Available globally, wherever the underlying EUDR Check has been performed.
- Results are valid for the specific EUDR Check result and time period they relate to.
Practical Details
- Turnaround: typically one week.
- Pricing: Available on request, both as individual assessments and as bundles (e.g. packs of five).
- How to order: Open to everyone – simply get in touch via EUDR@geocledian.com.
- Availability: No capacity or regional restrictions; assessments are performed on request wherever an EUDR Check result exists.
What the Expert Assessment Is – and Is Not
To position the service correctly within a due diligence process:
It is
- A structured, documented best-effort validation layer
- A tool to validate and rate detected deforestation risks before inducing other more costly follow on activities
- An auditable record demonstrating proportionate response to risk alerts
It is not
- A replacement for operator responsibility under EUDR
- A guarantee, in either direction, that deforestation has or has not occurred – remote assessment has inherent limits
- A substitute for on-site verification where local circumstances must be confirmed
Under EUDR, due diligence means exercising reasonable care – proportionate to the risk. The Expert Assessment is designed to help operators demonstrate exactly that: a measured, evidence-based response to a risk alert, neither ignoring it nor overreacting to it.
Summary
Automated deforestation checks scale; expert validation decides. The combination of both gives operators what neither delivers alone: efficient coverage of entire supply bases, and reliable, documented handling of the cases where it truly matters.
If you are interested in learning how the Expert Assessment could fit into your due diligence workflow – whether as a platform integrating our API or as an organisation running EUDR Checks directly – contact us at EUDR@geocledian.com.
Get in touch.
We’re here to help.
Feel free to reach out to us if you have any further
questions or inquiries.